raw almonds now unhealthy:

topic posted Fri, October 12, 2007 - 8:23 AM by  Patti
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
according to this:

On Friday, I blew the whistle on the FDA for allowing almond manufacturers to label pasteurized almonds as "raw." It's unethical and illegal—and it's tragic that such a nutritious food would be nutritionally castrated by the powers-that-be.

But what I didn't tell you on Friday is that there are plenty of issues beyond the fact that almonds will no longer be a nutritional heavyweight — like the fact that consuming them could now pose a threat to your health.

The pasteurization method the FDA is recommending requires the use of propylene oxide. Let me tell you a little something about the chemical that's supposed to make almonds safer for you to eat.

For starters, it's a recognized carcinogen. A pollution information site called Scorecard says that propylene oxide is in the top 10 percent of compounds that are hazardous to human health and to the ecosystem. In six out of twelve ranking systems, it's ranked as one of the most hazardous chemicals.

It's suspected of causing birth defects, of altering your immune system, and of adversely affecting your central nervous system, your reproductive system, your respiratory system, and your gastrointestinal tract, liver, and gallbladder.

And incidentally, propylene oxide has been banned in Canada, Mexico, and the European Union.

So why on earth would the Almond Board of California suggest that such a change be made in the first place? Simple: to save face. In the last five years, there have been two outbreaks in some of their biggest almond operations in California. That can't be too good for business. But this new gig they've got going on won't be good for business either.

Eighty percent of the almonds grown worldwide are grown in the States, which means that a good chunk of change comes from exportation. The problem: Pasteurized almonds are not permitted in many overseas countries. Domestic sales are bound to take a nosedive as well, as companies are now turning to overseas sources to get raw almonds that are REALLY raw.

But perhaps the biggest hit will be taken by the smaller almond operations. Truth be told, even though all of the problems originated with the biggest almond industries, this little piece of legislation could spell the end of the line for organic and small-time almond operations. The minimum cost of the pasteurization equipment is $500,000 — a hefty price that not many smaller businesses can afford. Shipping the almonds off to be pasteurized has its own road bumps, not the least of which includes higher prices tied up in transportation costs.

This is an awful lot of fuss, especially considering the fact that nuts are not likely to pose a threat in and of themselves. It's when manure or other fecal matter gets transferred to the crops that contamination can occur. A better solution is one that would regulate the manmade carelessness that's the source of all these problem to begin with. But with today's Band-aid mentality, the likelihood of that happening is almost nil.

Nutty for the truth,

William Campbell Douglass II, M.D.
posted by:
Patti
SF Bay Area
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: raw almonds now unhealthy:

    Fri, October 12, 2007 - 1:55 PM
    Thank you, Dr. Douglass! Well said.

    And thanks to you too, Patti, for sharing the good dr's courageous, but common sense, words of wisdom w/ us.

    I REALLY hope this ill-gotten pasteurization thing is extrememly short lived.

    Earth to People of Earth: WAKE UP!!!!!!!!!
  • Re: raw almonds now unhealthy:

    Fri, October 19, 2007 - 6:53 AM
    I live in the UK and the only almonds i can find for sale in the high-street are imported from the USA,
    You say Propylene oxide is banned in europe but doe's this also cover products treated with it or just the chemical itself?

    .....basicly just curious about if american almonds will still be exported or not?
    ....also when is this ridiculous practice supposed to come into force?
    (the almonds i buy now refuse to sprout for one reason or another)

    Thanks
  • pj
    pj
    online 10

    Re: raw almonds now unhealthy:

    Wed, December 3, 2008 - 10:44 AM
    Thanks for the article. We've been discussing the issue on this tribe and others for well over a year now. Nothing has changed.

    I was on a mission talking to everyone I know, including natural food store employees and managers who had no idea.
    I wrote letters/emails and received no response.
    Didn't have much of a bandwagon, though. Most people just resorted to finding a new source for their almonds even though this meant they would be shipped overseas. I have never felt this was an ideal solution.

    Throughout these threads there were several sources where truly raw almonds can be purchased were submitted. Tool around the site by punching raw almonds on the tribe's search engine. You may want to check out the raw superfood tribe also. This topic may have come up there as well. I believe we also discussed it on www.eat.rawfood.com.

    Now I have been reduced to staying vocal. If I see someone reach for the "raw" almonds at the market, I do not hesitate to inform them on this matter.

    So good health to all and keep spreading the word.

  • Re: raw almonds now unhealthy:

    Mon, January 19, 2009 - 8:10 PM
    does that apply for organic almonds too?
    • Unsu...
       

      Hope for raw almonds

      Tue, March 3, 2009 - 10:29 AM
      Apparently CODEX is in full swing on the almond issue as we speak.

      No raw organic almonds are allowed to be grown in the US. They are either sprayed with carcinogenic pesticides or are steamed prior to release to the public.

      Got my last batch as Italian imports, which I am certain CODEX will bring to a screeching halt once they figure out a way.

      This doesn't stop grocers, or even supposedly co-op type places from labeling the US grown almonds as "raw". Don't believe it unless they are imported. I approached the "nut master" at my local co-op and he knew the almonds were incorrectly labeled, but said his hands were tied. It's sad when the co-op starts lying.

Recent topics in "Raw Vegans"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Raw Thanksgiving Recipe Shares! Aron 0 Yesterday, 7:03 PM
When, and in what order to eat things...... Briggi 3 September 10, 2009
My favourite raw superfood recipes Sandra 0 September 1, 2009
Tian Gong Chance 0 August 25, 2009